I am not very familiar with liquid liner, so I brought it to practice, at one dollar it's not much of a loss if I didn't like it. This liner is so odd because when it dries it dries almost like a film and then cracks of bit by bit. It's not a good buy at all, but like I said, it's okay to practice if your a first timer.

The color is really pretty, but I was disappointed that it smears and comes off so easily. Seems like you would need to put alot of powder on your lids in order for this to stay on.

I received a sample Black ELF eyeliner in the Beauty Buyble and ahd heard a lot about the brand (mostly that it is so cheap) so I just had to try it, figuring it was crap. Was I surprised when I tried it and found how black and easy it goes on! Now I find myself consistently reaching for this eyeliner. The tip is soft and applies like a MAC liner. I usually reapply once during the day (as with most pencil liners), sometimes I don't have to reapply because this liner has such great staying powder. Although it lasts, it easily comes off with makeup remover.

I like this liner cause it is very smudgeable and the price is excellent.  The only problem with it is that it doesn't have staying power.

E.L.F. Brightening Eye Liner in Midnight:  This comes with a separate eye liner sharpener.  I have this in a stash of gifts to give (I have this extra stash for extras for unexpected birthdays and such).  The color Midnight, I thought looked black on the box, and just realized it is a nice navy blue.  Glides on nice, average wear.  Will smudge and doesn’t seem to last all day on my oily lids.  Nice blue shade though.  Can’t go wrong with a buck!

Testing Testing this 

This is a black eyeliner and I don't know why I got it! It makes my eyes look smaller! It's a good black pencil though!

I love this color of this pencil! It's like a light gold. It really is pretty. The stay  power is nil unless you use a eye primer! Otherwise I will definitely get again!

I don't like this color only because it doesn't show up on my skin tone (nw45). Its a very dark plum! And every time I sharpen the pencil and put the top on it breaks the point off! That sucks!